Murray Wood: Who's scary... and who's scary good?
Every Friday, Murray Wood takes a look at the week's news and decides who's hot... and who's not. This week, in a specia...
The 25 per cent tax on aluminum and steel coming into the United States starting March 12, and the possibility of retaliation tariffs, is expected to have cost ripples for buyers of beer, soup and everything else producers seal up in metal.
Read More:
- Canadian steel, aluminum hit by 25-per-cent tariffs by Donald Trump
- Trump steel, aluminum tariffs likely to drive up car costs, industry leaders say
- Canada’s business groups call for government action against U.S. tariffs
“It’s just another hit that the industry can’t take,” said CJ Hélie, president of Beer Canada.
“The magnitude and the timing, you know, couldn’t be worse.”
While almost 90 per cent of beer consumed in Canada is brewed here, most of the cans are imported, including the popular 473 millilitre size popular among craft breweries, he said.
U.S. manufacturers of cans import metal from Canada — the metal makes up about 70 per cent of the price of a can. Tariffs would make those imports more costly for the U.S. firms, in turn increasing the cost of those cans when they are sold back to Canadian companies.
If Canada imposes its own counter-tariffs, goods could be hit twice.
‘We’re still in an affordability crisis. Everybody is feeling it everywhere, and so if these tariffs and potential countermeasures by Canada come into play, brewers are going to face a very difficult decision,” said Hélie.
The industry faces aluminum tariffs that are much higher than the 10 per cent imposed during Trump’s last term, and while the tax may only amount to a few cents per can, the costs for the industry will be in the hundreds of millions of dollars, said Hélie.
The potential costs are also higher because cans keep growing in popularity over glass bottles, making up 75 per cent of sales in 2023, up from 53 per cent in 2015, the trade association said.
The previous round of tariff threats did lead to some increased domestic production of cans, but given the costs involved and the integrated nature of the two countries’ economies it was not easy to increase capacity, said Hélie.
Erick Vachon is one of those who saw an opportunity for domestic production as supply chains have become less reliable.
He co-founded Ideal Can in 2020 and now leads what he says is the only Canadian producer of food cans while also producing a range of other can offerings across three lines, each producing about 1,000 cans a minute.
Anticipating more demand for his domestically-produced cans, Vachon is working to add another shift to increase capacity and offset a bit of the hit.
“The tariff is bad for, of course, for Canadian people,” said Vachon.
“So I need to have three shifts a week, and of course we’re looking to increase the capacity of the factory.”
But it will hardly make a dent in demand, with Ideal Can’s capacity about 400,000 a year compared with consumption of what he said is about 1.8 billion cans a year in Canada.
The total can market affected by the tariffs and countermeasures is much larger. The U.S.-based Can Manufacturers Institute said about 25 billion cans were produced for human and pet food in 2023 for the U.S. and Canada, plus some 103 billion beer and soda cans.
The trade association has urged Trump to at least exempt tin mill steel from the tariffs, as, contrary to the intent of the tariffs, American producers ended up shutting down nine mill lines after Trump last imposed the import taxes on metal.
Others are still trying to understand the implications of the tariffs, especially with Canadian countermeasures still unclear.
“We’re not very clear with directions at this point how it is going to be taxed,” said Maresh Singh, a co-owner of Canadian Canning based in Hamilton, Ont.
“There’s a lot of uncertainty about this at this point.”
The distributor has about 80 per cent of its business in the U.S. and has manufacturers both there and in Canada as well as Mexico, underlining how integrated the market really is.
What he does know is that prices will go up with the tariffs.
“Certainly the products, the cost on the products, would go up for Americans. Definitely that is a fact.”
He said he hopes to have a better understanding of the implications in the days ahead, but one takeaway he already has is the need to boost supply security.
“Canada should have more production here in Canada itself, at least to safeguard Canadians versus such threats.”
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Feb. 12, 2025.
Ian Bickis, The Canadian Press
