The connection led to a meeting with Sheldon’s son, who entrusted Dayton with the artifacts, in hopes they would be preserved.
“We sat down, he started discussing all these things about the game and remembering bits and pieces. So he discussed the ball and he gave me the ball, ” Dayton recalled. “The game was at the armories, and he said there was between 2,000-2,100 people actually at the game all around, and they were wearing suit and tie and it was like a big thing back then.”

A photo of the Prince Albert All Stars that played against the Scottish National Team in 1921. (Nick Nielsen/paNOW)
The leather ball bears the signatures of every player who took part in the match. Inside, a golf ball can still be heard rattling around; it’s a superstition the Scottish players believed brought good luck.
The collection also includes the cleats worn by Sheldon, who was born in Glasgow before moving to Prince Albert in 1906. He continued playing locally until 1926 and became one of Saskatchewan’s most accomplished soccer players.

The Scottish National Team in 1921. Player names, in no particular order and according to canadiansoccerhistory.com: James Brownlie, William Bulloch, John McCormack, W. McAndrew, Craig Brown, James Scott, Neil McBain, Doug Thompson, Andy Wilson, Jim McMenemy, Alf Bennett, R.M.B. Orr, Jimmy Gordon, Joe Low, Willie Rankin, and Tom Maxwell. (Nick Nielsen/paNOW)
According to Saskatchewan Soccer, Sheldon was the province’s only player selected for Canada’s 1912 tour of England. He also represented Canada on the All-Canada XI that faced the touring Scottish side in Ottawa on July 9, 1921. Despite arriving after a train wreck delayed the team’s trip and left the Canadians without a practice, they lost just 1-0.
Sheldon was inducted into both the Prince Albert and Saskatchewan sports halls of fame before his death in 1974. His son has also since died.
More than a century after the Prince Albert match, Dayton hopes the artifacts can help reconnect descendants of the players on both sides of the Atlantic.
“It’d be nice to hear from (their relatives), and if we could do some research on the guys (who signed) the ball and we get contact with some of the family over there,” Dayton shared.
“Some of the family here that actually played the game would be fantastic. I would actually like to do a game.”










