Four premiers ask for greater say in superior, appeal court judge appointments

The premiers of Ontario, Quebec, Alberta and Saskatchewan are jointly calling on the federal government to give them more of a say in judges who are appointed to their superior and appeal courts.

They say in a letter to Prime Minister Mark Carney that having their governments actively engaged in the process will help ensure judicial appointments “appropriately reflect the diversity and the unique needs of each province and territory.”

Read more:

• Aviation experts to probe Air Canada flight after fatal crash at LaGuardia Airport
• ‘Hoodie-gate’: Is David Eby qualified as fashion police after dressing down B.C. MLA?
• Carney did not ‘proactively’ raise human rights or foreign interference with Xi: docs

The premiers are asking for the federal government to choose from a pool of candidates recommended and approved by the provinces when appointing judges to superior trial courts and courts of appeal.

Justice Minister Sean Fraser says that is not something his government is considering right now.

He says the federal government consults with provinces and territories during the process to get their feedback, and the process is working well.

The letter comes after Alberta Premier Danielle Smith made a similar request earlier this year, asking for more of a say on judicial appointments and threatening to withhold some court funding if that does not happen.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published March 24, 2026.